SILHOUETTES
By: Holly Strauss
A silhouette (-o-et’), is a portrait, especially a profile portrait, or a scene depicted in an outline that has been filled in with a solid color, usually black. The interior of a silhouette is featureless, and the image is typically presented on a light background, usually white. The silhouette differs from an outline, which depicts the edge of an object in a linear form, while a silhouette appears as a solid shape. Silhouette images may be created in any visual artistic media, but typically refer to images cut from black paper and affixed to a light background.
In pinpointing the origins of silhouette likenesses, also known as shade portraits or profile likenesses, art historians trace back to examples found in Paleolithic cave paintings, Egyptian hieroglyphics, Grecian vessels and the Chinese paper artwork of Antiquity.
The Greeks are known to have made silhouettes by tracing shadows cast by the sun. In the East, as early as the Tang dynasty (618-907), the Chinese were executing cut-paper designs that are close in feeling to silhouettes.
The silhouette is closely tied in mythology to the origins of art.
Pliny the Elder, in his Natural History (circa 77-79 AD) Books XXXIV and XXXV, recounts the origin of painting. In Chapter 5 of Book XXXV, he writes,
“We have no certain knowledge as to the commencement of the art of painting, nor does this enquiry fall under our consideration. The Egyptians assert that it was invented among themselves, six thousand years before it passed into Greece; a vain boast, it is very evident. As to the Greeks, some say that it was invented at Sicyon, others at Corinth; but they all agree that it originated in tracing lines round the human shadow.”
Profile portraits were the precursors to silhouettes and are strongly linked to them. For the depiction of portraits, the profile image has marked advantage over a full-face image in many circumstances because it depends strongly upon the proportions and relationship of the bony structures of the face, (the forehead, nose, and chin), making the image clear and simple.
For this reason, profile portraits have been employed on coinage since the Roman era. The early Renaissance period also saw a fashion for painted profile portraits.
The first profile likeness in the historical record is a non-extant rendering of Monarchs William and Mary by Elizabeth Rhijberg [“Ridge”-berg] in 1699, but the novelty’s heyday would not commence until the 1770’s. It was then that Swiss philosopher-preacher-scientist and physiognomist, [Physi-on-omist], Johann Caspar Lavater, [“Lava”-teer] who used silhouettes to analyze facial types, is thought to have promoted the art. Lavater catapulted profile likenesses into the international consciousness with the bestseller, Essays on Physionomy; For the Promotion of the Knowledge and the Love of Mankind (1774).
Physiognomy explores the relationship between facial features and personality traits. A machine called the physionotrace invented by Frenchman Gilles-Louis Chretien [“Gill”-is Lewis “Cray”-teen] in 1783-84 facilitated the production of silhouette portraits by casting a shadow on the subject’s profile and a machinist traced its outline. By deploying the mechanics of a pantograph to transmit the tracing (via an eyepiece) of the subject’s profile silhouette to a needle moving on an engraving plate, multiple portrait copies could be printed.
Lavater wrote: “To be a physiognomist, the study of silhouettes is most essential; it is by silhouettes, the physiognomist will exert and improve his tact; if he comprehends that language, he will possess an understanding of the countenance of man, he will read in it, as in an open book.”
While the tenents of this pseudo-science were never fully embraced by the academy, Lavater’s publications had the unintended effect of introducing profile likenesses as an inexpensive and instantaneously generated alternative to the traditional painted portrait.
In the West, the silhouette enjoyed its greatest popularity from the mid-eighteenth to the mid-nineteenth centuries. It was an inexpensive and accurate alternative to formal portraiture and also possessed a unique charm, capturing the essence of a personality with a minimum of detail and calling on the viewer to use his own imagination. In England, such works were generally known as “shades” or “shadow portraits” well into the nineteenth century.
The eponymous [“e”pon-e-mus”] term by which they are now known, is derived from Etienne de Silhouette (1709-67), the controller-general of France, who served during the reign of King Louis XV. In 1759, he was forced by France’s credit crisis during the Seven Years’ War to impose severe economic demands upon the French people, particularly the wealthy. Infamous for his austere financial policies, his name became synonymous with anything done or made cheaply. He amused himself by cutting portraits from paper.
It was during his tenure that profile likenesses produced by shadows became fashionable in France. Artists derisively referred to the cheap profile likenesses as portraits a la Silhouette. Thus, in the strictest sense, a silhouette is cut, either freehand, using the eye alone as a guide, or by following lines that have either been traced by the artists or drawn mechanically.
Cutting portraits, generally in profile, from black card became popular in the mid-18th century, though the term silhouette was not applied to the art of portrait-making until the early decades of the 19th century, and the tradition has continued under this name into the 21st century. In the 18th and early 19th century, “profiles” or “shades” as they were called were made by one of three methods.
Painted on ivory, plaster, paper, card, or in reverse on glass that could be used on jewelry, snuffboxes, lockets, etc.
“hollow-cut” or cut in reverse, i.e., where the negative image was traced and then the profile was cut away from white paper, the inner portion of which was discarded and the outer, negative portion, was then mounted on a dark background; and
“cut and paste” where the figure was cut out of dark paper (usually free-hand) and then pasted onto a light background.
Silhouettes were also painted, again either freehand or using some mechanical aids, such as a device called the Prosopographus, (Pros-o-pog-ra-fus), which used an automation to trace the profile. Silhouettes represented a cheap but effective alternative to the portrait miniature, and skilled specialist artists could “free cut” a high-quality bust portrait, by far the most common style, in a matter of minutes, working purely by eye.
Every art form has its own masters, and several artists became famous for their silhouettes. In England, the best known silhouette artist, a painter, not a cutter was John Miers, [“Myers”] (1756-1821). Miers travelled and worked in different cities before setting up studios on The Strand, in London around 1788. Here he operated a very successful business recording customers profiles in “three minute sittings.” Miers’ superior portraits could be in grisaille, (“griz-eye”), a painting in gray monochrome, with uncommon delicacy highlighted in gold or yellow. His miniatures were produced on various backings, including ivory, plaster or glass with delicate shading to show detail of hair and clothes. The sitters face was recorded as a black silhouette. The size was normally small to fit into a locket, but otherwise a bust some 3 to 5 inches high was typical, with half- or full-length portraits proportionately larger.
The 18th century silhouette artist, August Edouart, [ “Owe-“goose”-st “A”-dwar], (1769-1861), cut thousands of portraits in duplicate. His cut-paper portraits dazzle us with their technical virtuosity. Edouart emigrated from France to England following the Napoleonic Wars and focused on hair work before identifying a need in the art market for full-length likenesses cut freehand rather than by machine. Edouart found the likenesses produced by a machine to be inanimate and contemptible to his refined sensibilities. The long-suffering Edouart sought to establish a reputation as a freehand virtuoso and distinguish himself as an artist among machinist. He addressed these topics, among other grievances and vexations in A Treatise on Silhouette Likenesses (1835).
“Why does such prejudice exist against black shades, which I call Silhouette Likenesses? Persons who have an opportunity of judging and comparing my works, which have been executed by the hands, with those executed by mechanical process, cannot help making a comparison of the prices, even while they give me the preference for the execution of the work” (pp. 97-98)
Edouart’s subjects included French and British nobility and US presidents. From 1838-1846 he traveled to New York, Boston, and other locales. His goal was to create silhouette portraits of the most notable Americans he could find. By retaining the French name in the English-speaking world, Edouart infused “the poor man’s portrait” with a certain je ne sais quoi and distinguished his handmade likenesses from crude machine productions. Edouart always created duplicates of every subject. He gave one copy to the client and kept a copy for his archival files. In 1849, he returned to England aboard a ship called the “Onita.” It was shipwrecked, and most of his personal collection was lost.
Since the late 18th century, silhouette artists have also made small scenes cut from card and mounted on a contrasting background like the portraits. These pictures known as “paper cuts,” were often, but not necessarily, silhouette images. Among 19th century artists to work in this way was the author Hans Christian Andersen.
In the late 19th and early 20th century, several illustrators employed designs of similar appearance for making book illustrations. Silhouettes pictures could easily be printed by blocks that were cheaper to produce and longer lasting than detailed black and white illustrations. The famous English illustrator Arthur Rackham (1867-1939) executed two books, Cinderella and Sleeping Beauty, entirely in crisp, witty silhouettes.
By the turn of the 19th century, the advent of photographic portraits signaled the end of the silhouette as a widespread form of portraiture. While silhouette portraiture was considered passe’ to a majority of the population, a minority continued to support the art for various reasons. Traveling silhouette artists continued to work at state fairs into the 20th century. The popularity of the silhouette has been reborn in a new generation of people who appreciate the silhouette as a nostalgic way of capturing the linear nature of an individual’s profile in black and white transcending temporal limitations.
Silhouettes are still widely used today in advertising, theatre, film, photography and graphic design.
My interest in Silhouettes originated from a picture of several silhouettes hanging in a guest bedroom in Veranda Magazine. I liked the way the silhouettes were incorporated into the décor. Shortly after that, I purchased several silhouettes at a Brunk Auction. Unfortunately, I ended up putting them in a drawer, and they were tucked away for years.
My interest was piqued again by the impressive silhouette collection on the stairwell of Patricia Altschul, a character on the reality TV Show Southern Charm. Patricia’s Charleston house was decorated by one of my favorite decorators, Mario Buatta, and has been featured in Architectural Digest.
Before I began researching silhouettes, I had always associated them exclusively with busts hand cut from black paper; a novelty I enjoyed as a child at street fairs, carnivals, and amusement parks. After writing this paper, I realized how dynamic an art form they really are.